Excellent Executive Coaching Intelligence Blog · Executive Brief · Issue 04

The Board Member Who Criticizes Everything. How to Turn Your Board Into an Ally.

By Dr. Katrina Burrus, PhD, MCC · 3 minute read

The 30-second version

Year-end is review season in the boardroom, and many boards are frustrated with themselves as well as with management. A record 55% of directors say at least one colleague should be replaced. When a director criticizes everything, the cause is rarely you alone. It is usually missing information, unclear expectations or a political fault line. Fix the flow of information, agree on what success looks like, and build alliances before the meeting, not during it.

Four numbers to know this quarter

55%of US public company directors say at least one fellow director should be replaced, a record1
38%of directors name poor information flow as a barrier to an effective board and CEO relationship2
32%of executives say their board has the right mix of skills1
48%of executives want more international expertise on the board; only 8% of directors plan to add it1

Five moves for Monday morning

  1. Meet your critic one on one. Ask, “What would you need to see to feel confident in this plan?” Then listen without defending.
  2. Fix the information flow. Send fewer pages, earlier, with the decision you need on page one.
  3. Agree on what success looks like. Write down, with your chair, the three things the board expects from you this year.
  4. Build alliances between meetings. No important vote should be a surprise to any director.
  5. Ask the board for feedback on itself. A two-way review turns criticism into a shared standard.
Brilliant Jerk Watch

Boards have brilliant jerks too. Among directors who want a colleague replaced, 20% point to an interaction style that hurts board dynamics, and a quarter say collegiality is why nothing changes.1 Most difficult leaders are not cruel; they are anxious, and directors are no exception. What is a brilliant jerk?

Let’s look at your next best move.Facing a difficult board this review season? A confidential, politically neutral sparring partner helps. I am happy to schedule a call.

Sources: 1. PwC, 2025 Annual Corporate Directors Survey (Oct 2025), with executive data from PwC and The Conference Board. 2. NACD, 2025 Public Company Board Practices and Oversight Survey: Board-CEO Relationship (July 2025).

Read the full article, with charts, the trends for the year ahead, coaching guidance and all references →